Risk, returns & timeframes illustration
8 min read
April 9, 2024
by

Disney survived a hostile takeover, what have we learned?

Disney beat Nelson Peltz in his battle for boardroom control, ending years of struggles that kicked off during Covid. Retired CEO Bob Iger returned to bring the legacy entertainer back from big losses, but he can’t stay forever. So what happened behind closed doors during the failed hostile takeover?
Disney beat Nelson Peltz but has bigger battles ahead like finding a new CEO
8 min read
April 9, 2024
by

Disney survived a hostile takeover, what have we learned?

Disney beat Nelson Peltz in his battle for boardroom control, ending years of struggles that kicked off during Covid. Retired CEO Bob Iger returned to bring the legacy entertainer back from big losses, but he can’t stay forever. So what happened behind closed doors during the failed hostile takeover?
8 min read
April 9, 2024
by

Disney survived a hostile takeover, what have we learned?

Disney beat Nelson Peltz in his battle for boardroom control, ending years of struggles that kicked off during Covid. Retired CEO Bob Iger returned to bring the legacy entertainer back from big losses, but he can’t stay forever. So what happened behind closed doors during the failed hostile takeover?
Table of contents
Getting Started Investing course
Free Getting Started Course
Take your first, or next, step to becoming a confident investor with Hatch's free online course – just 10 minutes a day, for 10 days.
The Fry up logo with fried egg
Weekly news from Wall St
Subscribe to The Fry Up - your weekly sizzle of headline-grabbing share market news. Read by 65,000 Kiwis to help them take charge of their investing journey.

Is all well in the House of Mouse following an attempted hostile takeover? 🏰 The management team and board at Disney (DIS) may have let out a collective sigh of relief last week. The blue chip entertainment company survived their second attempted hostile takeover by 81-year-old billionaire shareholder Nelson Peltz - father of Nicole Peltz, married to Brooklyn Beckham - who was handed a ‘stinging defeat’. 

In the countercampaign against Peltz, which cost an estimated US$40 million, Disney CEO Bob Iger reached out for support from big names. These included Star Wars creator George Lucas, former Disney CEO Michael Eisner, JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon and businesswoman Laurene Powell Jobs, the widow of Apple CEO Steve Jobs. Disney also gained backing - and much-needed shareholder votes - from large institutional investors, including Vanguard, which owns a 7.8% stake in Disney, BlackRock with 4.2%, and State Street owning 4.1%.

Why did Peltz want a seat at Disney’s table?

Trian Partners controls a US$3.98 billion stake in Disney: 1.8%. 💰 The majority stake is owned by Ike Perlmutter, however, who pledged control of his Disney shareholding to Peltz in support of his proxy battle. Trian Partners, the hedge fund firm founded by Peltz, alleged that Disney had ‘lost its way over the past decade’, adding that Disney has ‘a board that lacks focus, alignment and accountability’. 

A hostile takeover attempt occurs when ‘activist shareholders want changes in a company’. Self-confessed ‘bully billionaire’ Peltz launched his second proxy fight in late 2023, a battle that cost around US$25 million, which he had to part-fund. Peltz’s aim was to gain some control of the 12-person Disney board by unseating Maria Elena Lagomasino and Michael Froman, replacing them with former Disney CFO Jay Rasulo and Peltz himself. This required a campaign to solicit shareholder votes in the run-up to the AGM to secure the two seats - including to gain votes from the one-third Disney retail investors

Peltz’s proxy fight rallied camps on both sides. 🥊 Elon Musk, who’s waged his own battle with Disney following the company pulling advertising from his X/Twitter in November last year alleging Musk’s anti-semitic comments, tweeted his support of Peltz. In the Disney camp, Walt Disney’s grandchildren publicly expressed support for Iger:

‘We know that our grandfather would be especially proud of what Disney means to the world today. We also know that, like us, he would be very concerned by the threat posed by self-anointed ‘activist investors’ who are really wolves in sheep’s clothing, just waiting to tear Disney apart if they can trick shareholders into opening the door for them.’ — Disney grandchildren, The Hollywood Reporter

But Trian Partners - along with Blackwells Capital which had also pushed to gain three board seats - failed to win any board seats. 

Did Disney’s strong Q1 performance diffuse Trian’s argument?

The Disney empire strikes back. 💥 Disney’s 2024 first quarter ‘blockbuster’ earnings results quashed some board concerns about a potential crumbling empire. Announcements included: 

  • Increasing operating income by 27%, cost savings tallying US$7.5 billion - which included laying off thousands of employees
  • Lifting earnings per share (EPS) to 23%
  • Reporting a free cash flow of US$886 million in Q4 2023 and setting a target to reach total cash flow of US$8 billion in 2024 - returning Disney to pre-Covid levels
  • Investing US$60 billion into theme parks to grow their experience business
  • All bookended with 27 Golden Globe nominations, and announcing a slate of high profile movie releases - including Deadpool, Alien, Moana, Avatar, Frozen 3 and Toy Story and the highly-anticipated Disney and Lucasfilm Star Wars movie, The Mandalorian & Grogu, set for release mid-2026

The Journal podcast by WSJ, Robbie Whelan added that Disney’s reporting had ‘everything you could ever want’, summarising:

‘Had Taylor Swift. They announced that she was going to do an exclusive cut of her Eras tour movie on Disney Plus. We had Fortnite, the most popular video game in the world. Disney was making a huge investment in Epic Games, the owners of Fortnite and striking a big partnership with him. We had Nick Saban, the most beloved college football coach of the last decade from Alabama. They were hiring him to be a commentator on ESPN, and they announced probably biggest of all, a big joint venture with Warner Brothers and Fox where they're going to launch a sports-focused streaming service. In addition, quarterly earnings were really good.’ - Robbie Whelan, The Journal podcast, WSJ

Following last week’s AGM vote, Disney stock dropped 4.02%. However, the US$215.255 billion market cap company’s stock has climbed 29.97% year-to-date (YTD) and is up 17.47% year-over-year (YOY) - growth that boostedTrian’s portfolio by nearly 30% - around US$1 billion.

What companies does Disney own?

Does Disney own the world? 🌏 It might be easier to ask which companies doesn’t the legacy company own; Disney’s list of assets is vast. Among them are Lucasfilm, Marvel, Touchstone Pictures, Pixar - with film franchises including Star Wars, Narnia, The Muppets and Winnie the Pooh -  ESPN (80% stake), Hulu, ABC, Hollywood Records, Core Publishing, Vice Media (10% stake), The History Channel (50% equity holding with Hearst Corporation), Lifetime (50% equity holding with Hearst Corporation) and A&E (50% equity holding with Hearst Corporation).

Along with a tonne of companies ‘we’ve never heard of’, they also own their own-name brands - their ‘cash cows’ - Disney Plus, Disney stores, Disney radio stations and Disney parks - which includes Walt Disney World Resort, Disneyland Resort, Disneyland Paris - and their global Disney Cruise Line, along with vacation-related properties. 

‘Parks are now a third of revenue and 3/4 of profitability. So parks have to continue to do well to drive earnings per share growth, and I expect that they will.’ — Laura Martin, Yahoo Finance

Who will be Disney’s next CEO?

Disney may not be out of the hundred acre woods yet. 🌲 Long term Disney investors have weathered plenty of storms - such as shareholder dividends cut to $0 between 2021 and 2023 when revenue from the Parks and Cruise Line plummeted during lockdowns - and Disney still faces a ‘checklist of concerns’. 

Among them include Peltz returning to fight another day should Disney fail in shareholder expectations, and the ongoing battle to gain subscribers on Hulu and Disney+ - numbers still well below main competitor Netflix (NFLX), with Disney+ bleeding 1.3 million subscribers in Q1, down to 149.6 million - a drop of 12 million in one year - which compares to Netflix’s 260.28 million.

Disney needs to magic a strong CEO. ✨ Highest on the list is the global search to find a CEO successor to Bob Igor, who had returned from an 11-month retirement from the company to fill the role, and receives a US$31.6 million pay package, but is expected to step down in 2026. Rumours swirl, with possible contenders including Disney’s potential first female CEO, Dana Walden. For now, shareholders - and Peltz - watch and wait.

Like this? 👍 Then you might like: Could AI help you have a baby? 👶

Never miss a Hatch article. Follow the feed on Google News! 📰

We’re not financial advisors and Hatch news is for your information only. However dazzling our writing, none of it is a recommendation to invest in any of the companies or funds mentioned. If you want support before making any investment decisions, consider seeking financial advice from a licensed provider. We’ve done our best to ensure all information is current when we pushed ‘publish’ on this article. And of course, with investing, your money isn’t guaranteed to grow and there’s always a risk you might lose money.

Join the Kiwis who are hatching their tomorrow and have invested more than $1 billion with Hatch.

Explore another series
Tax
Money
Economy
Investing

More recent news articles

Recent learn articles

5 min read
Oct 1, 2024

Space Race: 10,000 satellites orbiting Earth just the start

The space race is a big money game. But it seems there are really only two big contenders vying for NASA contracts. Elon Musk’s SpaceX has been leading in what seems like a monopoly. But Kiwi challenger Rocket Lab is nipping at their heels with their largest rocket yet, Neutron, due to hit the skies in 2025.
Read more
4 min read
Sep 11, 2024

In Briefs: Allbirds and On - Sneaker Showdown

Formerly a Silicon Valley staple, has Allbirds strayed too far from its lane in chasing zero carbon? It’s undergoing a stock split and on the brink of delisting, while competition Swiss shoe company On is sprinting ahead with impressive growth and podium finishes.
Read more
7 min read
Aug 20, 2024

Was August’s ‘Manic Monday’ a storm in a teacup?

July US job market data was just one catalyst for August’s US share markets’ ‘Manic Monday’. The fear index had been climbing since mid-July, Bank of Japan hiked interest rates, and the Nikkei plummeted 10% in two days. So how are global share markets connected, and could a Texas Stock Exchange boost the American economy?
Read more

Related news articles

More recent learn articles

6 min read
Jul 9, 2024

Can Nike’s Olympic dream rebound stock after 20% plummet?

Kiwi athletes are not the only ones aiming for Olympic gold in Paris this July. Nike is pinning hopes on the ‘pinnacle’ event to gain exposure, with the Olympic Committee for the first time allowing non-sponsor brands to post Olympic content in social media. Could the Games help Nike reach for gold, up from their expected 10% sales dip?
Read more
6 min read
May 28, 2024

The US vs Live Nation; stocks fall nearly 8% in a day

Following Ticketmaster’s Taylor Swift ticketing blunder, Tay-Tay's fans united fans to sue music event behemoth Live Nation. Now, after two years of investigation, the US Department of Justice has banded together with nearly 30 US states and have sued parent, Live Nation Entertainment. So what do they allege, and can they win?
Read more
7 min read
May 7, 2024

Street-fighter mode: McD’s supersizing burgers to win customers

McDonald’s CEO Chris Kempczinski says they’re feeling the loss of low earning customers during the high cost of living, promising to bring back value dining, as well as creating their biggest burger ever. But one financial analyst has dug into the data, and he tells a different story.
Read more

Recent news articles

More recent learn articles

5 min read
Oct 1, 2024

Space Race: 10,000 satellites orbiting Earth just the start

The space race is a big money game. But it seems there are really only two big contenders vying for NASA contracts. Elon Musk’s SpaceX has been leading in what seems like a monopoly. But Kiwi challenger Rocket Lab is nipping at their heels with their largest rocket yet, Neutron, due to hit the skies in 2025.
Read more
4 min read
Sep 11, 2024

In Briefs: Allbirds and On - Sneaker Showdown

Formerly a Silicon Valley staple, has Allbirds strayed too far from its lane in chasing zero carbon? It’s undergoing a stock split and on the brink of delisting, while competition Swiss shoe company On is sprinting ahead with impressive growth and podium finishes.
Read more
7 min read
Aug 20, 2024

Was August’s ‘Manic Monday’ a storm in a teacup?

July US job market data was just one catalyst for August’s US share markets’ ‘Manic Monday’. The fear index had been climbing since mid-July, Bank of Japan hiked interest rates, and the Nikkei plummeted 10% in two days. So how are global share markets connected, and could a Texas Stock Exchange boost the American economy?
Read more