Risk, returns & timeframes illustration
7 min read
May 17, 2021
by
Amanda Broughton

Property vs Shares: A battle of the heavyweights

For the title fight in battle of the assets, it’s property vs shares! In one corner, property: an established investing heavyweight - thanks to prices rising sevenfold in the past three decades - and beloved by generations of Kiwis. In the other corner, shares: an established global player that’s sparring for the top title on the NZ investing scene
7 min read
May 17, 2021
by
Amanda Broughton

Property vs Shares: A battle of the heavyweights

For the title fight in battle of the assets, it’s property vs shares! In one corner, property: an established investing heavyweight - thanks to prices rising sevenfold in the past three decades - and beloved by generations of Kiwis. In the other corner, shares: an established global player that’s sparring for the top title on the NZ investing scene
7 min read
May 17, 2021
by
Amanda Broughton

Property vs Shares: A battle of the heavyweights

For the title fight in battle of the assets, it’s property vs shares! In one corner, property: an established investing heavyweight - thanks to prices rising sevenfold in the past three decades - and beloved by generations of Kiwis. In the other corner, shares: an established global player that’s sparring for the top title on the NZ investing scene
Table of contents
Getting Started Investing course
Free Getting Started Course
Take your first, or next, step to becoming a confident investor with Hatch's free online course – just 10 minutes a day, for 10 days.
The Fry up logo with fried egg
Weekly news from Wall St
Subscribe to The Fry Up - your weekly sizzle of headline-grabbing share market news. Read by 65,000 Kiwis to help them take charge of their investing journey.

When it comes to putting your money to work, there are lots of options. Two of the most talked about contenders vying for our attention in New Zealand - especially in the media - are investing in property and the share markets. So what’s better, and should you invest in property or stocks?

Why has property been such an aspirational investment?

In the late 1970s, investing in property started to gain momentum when house prices were cheaper relative to salaries. In fact, the ratio of house price to income was around two times the median household income. By the mid 1980’s Rogernomics arrived, bringing with it deregulation of banking, and removal of controls on lending and interest rates. People were then able to borrow larger sums to buy a property, rent it out in almost any condition (no such thing as Healthy Homes standards until 2022) and benefit from tax-free capital gains when they sold it. When it came to choosing between property vs shares, it was almost a no-brainer. 

As reported by Stats NZ, at the year ending June 2022, the average annual household income was $117,126, while average house prices were around $989,790. That’s a ratio of 8.45. New Zealand house prices have fallen more than 10% between July 2022 and July 2023, which brings the ratio down to around 7.5. But that’s still far above the glory days of the 1970s when the ratio was just 2.

Property has also been what’s considered a ‘tangible asset’, which means it has a physical address, and you can see and touch it. And with Kiwis having DIY in their DNA, property investors may benefit financially from the physical work they put into house maintenance and upkeep. 

But with tighter regulations, higher costs, and less potential for large capital gains, the ‘golden age’ of Kiwi property ownership looks increasingly like it may be coming to an end. So, are shares better than property? Or is property better than shares? 

Share market investing has gained new fans

The 1987 stock market crash saw a lot of Kiwis caught in the fallout, and put many off investing in the stock markets for years. But since then there’s been a sea change in the way Kiwis invest. While once some people looked to owning property for their retirement payout, when 2007 rolled around, along came KiwiSaver. KiwiSaver is New Zealand’s voluntary savings scheme aimed to help people put money aside and invest for their future. Today more than three million New Zealanders have signed up to it. Despite expected ups and downs and a sometimes volatile share market, KiwiSaver has shown that over time investments have been able to provide returns and help build long-term wealth. 

Since around 2016 New Zealanders – particularly younger Kiwis – have embraced the opportunity to invest in the share markets. By buying a slice of the companies that they use and love, and hoping that as the companies grow profit over time, they - as investors - can share in the success over the long term. 

With retail investing now more accessible, New Zealanders have increased exposure to investing in shares. There are so many finance and investing podcasts, social media accounts, YouTube channels and websites that help people to understand how the share markets work, how to research shares, and to buy and sell shares in a company. Yep, it’s become simpler, cheaper and quicker than ever!

How much cash do you need to invest in property, vs shares?

While $300 NZD could buy 20 litres of paint, a basic bathroom vanity or a block of cheese, it’s not going to get you an investment property. Fractional shares make investing in stocks more affordable. And while co-ownership in a house is technically a fraction of an investment, fronting up ½ or even ¼ of a house deposit requires significantly more cash than the cost of most shares on the share markets today. So how much do you need for an investment property deposit in NZ? 

The median house price in NZ in mid-2023 was$780,000 NZD at a time when most banks required a minimum 35% deposit from people looking to buy an investment property. Based on that number being more-or-less true today, that’s potentially around $273,000 NZD in cash and spare equity in your current property that you’ll need to find to get the deposit required for a rental property in NZ.

Many share trading platforms in New Zealand don’t have minimum investment requirements, which means shares are a more accessible option when you don’t have a lot of money to begin with. To help you decide how much you’ll need to get started investing in stocks and shares it pays to look at fees on any platforms you choose as it can have a significant impact on your returns in the future.

What have property law changes meant for investors?

Giving tenants safer and more secure housing? Check. More responsibilities for landlords? Check!  

Since 2019, there have been changes to New Zealand laws that have been likely to affect property investors: 

Property investors have to adjust their expectations around rental profits. This is because it becomes increasingly difficult to find a property that can cover all the expenses through rent only. This includes:

  • Mortgage repayments 
  • Insurance 
  • Maintenance and repairs
  • Property management fees (or your own time) 
  • Cash reserves in case of missed rent or vacancies 
  • Rates 
  • Body corporate fees (if in a multi-unit) 

Being a landlord is definitely not always a hands-off investment! It can sometimes be time consuming, and some people may find it stressful. Owning property can include jobs like:  

  • Monitoring ongoing rent payments 
  • Quarterly property inspections 
  • Finding and vetting tenants 
  • Managing maintenance requests 
  • Filing tenancy contracts and bonds 
  • Dealing with disputes and evictions (which also got more difficult with changes to tenancy laws) 
  • Paying tax on rental incomes

Property owners can of course hire a property manager. But they need to make sure they set aside up to 5-10% of rental income as a baseline fee to cover costs. Add to this the recent changes in lending restrictions on investors, people looking to own property now need a 35% deposit to buy. And for some, that may be a heavy hit! 

Perhaps it’s no wonder that since 2021, landlord numbers have declined. The number of Kiwis who own at least one rental property has dropped by 8% since 2015, according to MBIE data.

Pros and cons of investing in shares vs property:

The battle Share market investing Property investing The winner
Returns on your hard earned cash The S&P 500, which tracks the top 500 companies on the US share markets, historically has "grown by an average of 10% a year for over the past 30 years." * House prices in New Zealand have grown by an average of 5.8% each year since 1990.* Share market investing
Cost of entry You can start with whatever amount works within your budget, $100, $1,000, $10,000 or more. A basic entry-level rental in a main centre might cost you $600k-$800k with a 35% deposit. Share market investing
Leverage With shares, you need all of the money upfront - unless you have a margin account which can be risky business. You also can't borrow any extra money on your shares. When you buy a property with a mortgage, you borrow the bank's money to buy an asset that is more expensive than you could afford on your own. You can then borrow against your house to buy a rental property. Property investing
Convenience (and (liquidity) - how easily can you get your money out) Shares are simply bought and sold and require no maintenance. ‘Set and forget’ may be a convenient way to help towards growing your money over the long term. Property can take months to sell, has high transaction costs and legal fees, maintenance can be intensive, and property management needs regular attention. Share market investing
(Volatility) (how much values can go up or down in a short time period of time) Share markets are known to be up or down on any given day. Short-term share investing can be riskier than investing for the long term. Property investing bubbles can “burst” (mid-1990s, 2003, 2013, 2015, 2021) but there can be significantly less short-term volatility. Both!

*Past performance does not equal future performance

Property still punches hard

Considering all this information, why might property investing still be where so many people choose to put their money? One reason is familiarity. It’s easy for people to understand buying and selling a house - that tangible asset. We’ve all lived in houses, many of us have been tenants in someone else’s house, and we’ve seen other Kiwis make money - sometimes huge chunks of cash - when they sell. Investing in property vs shares has often meant going with what you know, while in comparison, share market investing may have seemed less familiar.  

Plus, the share markets can be a bit bumpy. Most share markets have ‘corrections’ where share prices can drop by 10% on average every 16 months. A fall of 20% is called a bear market and happens on average every four years. But keep in mind, even with these bumps, over the long term, the share markets have historically gone up on average 10% each year.

And the winner is…

Property investing may make sense for some folks, and we think it’s important to diversify your portfolio by spreading your money across a range of investments. But when it comes to investing in a rental property, tens of thousands of dollars are needed up front for an investment property deposit in NZ (and then you’ll have the lawyers’ fees) and there’s no guarantee of a big cash profit when it comes time to selling a property, as the 2023 markets showed. While the same ‘no guarantee’ of profit can be said for share market investing, it has lower up front costs and, thankfully, doesn’t ever need the roof fixed or the lawns mowed. 

The same investing strategies can apply to both property and shares

So how can you set yourself up for investing, whether you choose property or shares? 

  • Don’t put all your eggs in one basket – if you aren’t sure if you want to invest in property or shares, choosing a mix of both can be a way to diversify your investments.
  • Pay yourself first – commit to investing regularly, just like you’d commit to regularly paying a mortgage on a rental property, even if it’s only a small amount.
  • Invest in yourself – learn while you go - the more you know, the better you’ll be when you hit bumps along the way.  
  • Have the best of both worlds! - you can invest in the property industry through REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) on the US share markets. 

Read more about REITs

If you’re considering investing in the share markets, a simple way to learn the basics is to spend 10 minutes a day for 10 days on our free beginner investor’s Getting Started Course, and browse our investing articles that help you learn how to research shares. 

Watch: The Great Debate - Property and Shares

Amanda Broughton
Finance writer
Linkedin

We’re not financial advisors and Hatch news is for your information only. However dazzling our writing, none of it is a recommendation to invest in any of the companies or funds mentioned. If you want support before making any investment decisions, consider seeking financial advice from a licensed provider. We’ve done our best to ensure all information is current when we pushed ‘publish’ on this article. And of course, with investing, your money isn’t guaranteed to grow and there’s always a risk you might lose money.

Join the Kiwis who are hatching their tomorrow and have invested more than $1 billion with Hatch.

Explore another series
Tax
Money
Economy
Investing

More recent news articles

Recent learn articles

3 min read
Sep 26, 2024

How to build financial wellbeing starting with a money buffer

Financial wellbeing is wellbeing, and small steps today can help you reach your goals faster and reduce stress along the way. Here are 5 simple steps to help get your money working smarter and take the worry away.
Read more
3 min read
Aug 29, 2024

Warren Buffett quotes: Lessons on investing from the Oracle of Omaha

At 94 years young, famous US investor Warren Buffett has learned a few painful billion dollar lessons along the way. But the man famous for enjoying McDonald’s for brekkie and Dairy Queen on Sunday is still not afraid to fail.
Read more
7 min read
Jul 30, 2024

The ASX 200: Australia’s main stock market index

The ASX, or Australian Securities Exchange, is renowned for its strong focus on the banking and mining sectors and its good market depth and liquidity. With a history dating back to the 1800s, today it features in the top 20 largest stock exchanges in the world.
Read more

Related news articles

More recent learn articles

3 min read
Sep 26, 2024

How to build financial wellbeing starting with a money buffer

Financial wellbeing is wellbeing, and small steps today can help you reach your goals faster and reduce stress along the way. Here are 5 simple steps to help get your money working smarter and take the worry away.
Read more
8 min read
Aug 22, 2023

What’s the difference between saving and investing?

Not sure whether you should save your money or invest it? We’ve covered the definition of saving money, and given a solid investment definition along with pros and cons of each, so you can decide what works for you.
Read more
6 min read
Jun 29, 2023

What is dollar-cost averaging?

Dollar-cost averaging (DCA) is an investment strategy that can help manage risk. Learn how dollar cost averaging works so you can decide if this strategy suits your investment goals.
Read more

Recent news articles

More recent learn articles

3 min read
Sep 26, 2024

How to build financial wellbeing starting with a money buffer

Financial wellbeing is wellbeing, and small steps today can help you reach your goals faster and reduce stress along the way. Here are 5 simple steps to help get your money working smarter and take the worry away.
Read more
3 min read
Aug 29, 2024

Warren Buffett quotes: Lessons on investing from the Oracle of Omaha

At 94 years young, famous US investor Warren Buffett has learned a few painful billion dollar lessons along the way. But the man famous for enjoying McDonald’s for brekkie and Dairy Queen on Sunday is still not afraid to fail.
Read more
7 min read
Jul 30, 2024

The ASX 200: Australia’s main stock market index

The ASX, or Australian Securities Exchange, is renowned for its strong focus on the banking and mining sectors and its good market depth and liquidity. With a history dating back to the 1800s, today it features in the top 20 largest stock exchanges in the world.
Read more